Updated May 2026 · Redfin · 3-month window
11953 Real Estate Market Update: Middle Island, NY, May 2026
The latest housing-market numbers for ZIP code 11953 in Middle Island, New York, for May 2026: a $440K median sale price, straight from the Redfin Data Center. ZIP-level figures are a rolling three-month window.
| Metric | Value | MoM | YoY |
|---|---|---|---|
| Median sale price | $440K | ▼ -1.7% | ▲ +6.0% |
| Days on market | 37 | ▼ -23.7% | ▼ -2.6% |
| Homes for sale | 32 | ▼ -11.1% | ▼ -34.7% |
| Sale-to-list | 99.4% | ▲ +0.3% | ▼ -1.3% |
| Homes sold | 58 | ▲ +1.8% | ▲ +28.9% |
Figures from the Redfin Data Center ZIP-code tracker (rolling 3-month window, not seasonally adjusted). Verify against your MLS before posting. Not a valuation for a specific home.
What the 11953 numbers say
Prices in Middle Island's 11953 ZIP are still climbing. The median sale price reached $440,000, up 6.0% year over year. Pace is steady: a typical listing goes under contract in about 37 days, with sellers getting 99.4% of list price.
Based on 58 recent sales, 11953 is currently an active market.
What this means if you sell in 11953
Use these figures to set expectations early with each client. Lead a listing appointment with the $440K median price and the 37-day pace, show the year-over-year direction, and frame 11953 as an active market. A buyer or seller client trusts an agent who knows their exact ZIP, not just the metro average.
How we track the 11953 market
We built LOKAL to pull 11953's numbers straight from the Redfin Data Center, so an agent and a client read from the same source. For May 2026 we recorded a $440K median sale price, +6.0% year over year, a 99.4% sale-to-list ratio and a -1.7% month-over-month move across 58 recorded sales. That compares with roughly $415K a year earlier, in 2025. We refresh every ZIP monthly and only publish once a ZIP clears at least 20 recorded sales for the period, so the median stays reliable instead of noisy. Redfin has published ZIP-level market data monthly since 2020, which is what lets us show month-over-month and year-over-year change here in 2026. LOKAL is independent and not affiliated with Redfin; always verify against your MLS before you publish.
ZIP-code areas follow U.S. Postal Service boundaries; for complementary demographics on 11953 — population, median household income, owner-occupancy — see the U.S. Census Bureau profile for this ZIP Code Tabulation Area. LOKAL covers price and pace; the Census covers who lives there.
Turn these 11953 numbers into a finished post.
Open LOKAL with Middle Island ready to go. You'll get a carousel, story and square graphic with real figures in place, ready to export in seconds.
Build the Middle Island post →Frequently asked: the 11953 housing market
- What is the median home price in ZIP 11953 (Middle Island, NY)?
- As of May 2026, the median sale price in ZIP 11953 is $440,000 (+6.0% year over year), per the Redfin Data Center. Figures are a rolling 3-month window for this ZIP code.
- Is ZIP 11953 a buyer's or seller's market right now?
- ZIP 11953 is currently an active market, based on a 99.4% sale-to-list ratio, about 37 days on market for May 2026.
- How long do homes take to sell in ZIP 11953?
- A typical listing in 11953 goes under contract in about 37 days as of May 2026. Always verify against your local MLS before quoting figures to clients.
- Where does this 11953 market data come from?
- All figures come from the Redfin Data Center ZIP-code market tracker, a rolling 3-month window refreshed monthly. LOKAL turns them into a ready-to-post carousel, story and square graphic. LOKAL is not affiliated with Redfin.
More New York markets
Nearby New York ZIP codes
Embed this update on your site
Data: Redfin · Redfin Data Center (ZIP-code market tracker). Figures are a ZIP-level 3-month snapshot, not a valuation for a specific home.